How should an AI agent show you it's working?

A download knows its size. An AI agent doesn't know how many steps a task will take until it has taken them. So how should it show you it's working, without a fake percentage or a bar that never ends? Here's what we got wrong, and the four rules nox.cool follows now.

Blog7 min readThe nox.cool team

A big blue painted face glowing in the middle, a sleeping yellow face and a sleeping green face on either side, and a bar a third full below

Key points

  • No made-up percentages. An AI agent decides its next step after seeing the last one, so nobody knows how far along a task is. nox.cool never shows a number it can't stand behind.
  • Never start over. One long task fills the bar on Nox's Mac Dock icon slowly, close to half after four minutes, and it never jumps back to empty.
  • Waiting isn't working. A task waiting for your answer, or for nox.cool's AI to come back, shows no progress at all.
  • Show who, not just what. Each agent has its own colour, and the page you're on is lit in it, in the light and the dark theme.

An AI agent should show you three things without being asked: which agent is at work, whether its work is really moving, and when it needs you. It should never pretend to know how far along it is, because it can't. That's how nox.cool shows work, as of 20 November 2026.

This post is about why those are the right three things, what we got wrong on the way, and how it looks in practice.

Why is "how far along?" so hard for an AI agent?

A download knows its size before it starts. A file copy knows how many files there are. Their progress bars are honest because the end is known.

An AI agent's task has no known end. Ask Nox to "find a quiet hotel in Lisbon under £250 a night" and the plan might be: search, open six hotels, read their reviews, compare. But if the third hotel's reviews mention building work next door, it goes back and checks the others for the same thing. If a booking site wants a date it doesn't have, it stops and asks you. Each step is chosen after seeing the result of the last one.

So a task that looks like six steps can take twenty. Any percentage would be a guess with a decimal point on it, and people quite reasonably read a percentage as a promise.

A progress bar that starts over is a promise broken every twenty seconds.

The bar that looked like a download

Nox for Mac puts a bar on its icon in the Dock while your agents work, the way a browser does while a file downloads. This month, one of us opened the Mac and asked a simple question: "What is Nox downloading? It never stops."

It wasn't downloading anything. The bar had two problems, and together they made it look broken.

It started over. With one task at work, Nox can't know how far along it is, so the bar swept from empty to full every 20 seconds and began again. We'd meant it to say "busy, no promises". To a person, a bar that fills up and starts again says "another download", over and over.

It counted a task that wasn't moving. That task had asked its owner a question, got the answer, and was then waiting for nox.cool's AI to come back, which took days. The task was safe and said so in the chat, but the bar kept sweeping, because the server counted any task that wasn't finished as "at work".

A week of a bar sweeping for nothing taught us more than any design review. Both problems are fixed now, and they gave us the rules below.

Four rules for showing an AI agent's work

1. Don't invent a percentage

Show only what's known: that work is happening, how long it's been going, which step it's on, and how many of several tasks are done. All of those are facts. "47% complete" for a single open-ended task isn't.

2. Never start over

Some feeling of progress still helps: a bar that sits still looks frozen. So with one task at work, the bar on Nox's Dock icon now fills slowly from the moment the task began. It's close to half after four minutes, then creeps on more and more slowly, and it never reaches the end or jumps back to empty. It only goes when the task is done.

A quick task never shows a bar at all: it has to run for 15 seconds first. With several tasks, the bar becomes an honest count instead, how many have finished since they began, just as a list of downloads would show it.

3. Waiting isn't working

A task waiting for you, or waiting on us, isn't making progress, so it shouldn't look like it is. On nox.cool:

  • A task that needs your OK shows a card in its chat with exactly what it wants to do, and the number on Nox's Dock icon counts it. No bar.
  • A task waiting for nox.cool's AI to come back says so in plain words in its chat ("your task is safe, and carries on by itself when it's back") and shows no bar.
  • When it picks up again, it counts as work again.

So a moving bar always means something is moving.

4. Show who, not just what

Once you have more than one agent, "something is working" isn't enough. You want to know which. Every agent on nox.cool already wears its own paint colour on its face. Now the page you're on is lit in that colour, which is the subject of the next section.

Which agent is it? A light in its colour

Behind every page there's a soft light in the colour of the agent the page is about. Researcher is blue, so its home and its chats glow blue. Inbox is green. Nox is yellow.

Researcher's home on nox.cool: a blue 3D face in the middle, a soft blue light behind the page, and the agent's card on the right
Researcher's page, lit in its own blue.

The rules are simple:

  • An agent's home and its chats use that agent's colour.
  • A task uses the colour of the agent doing it, however you got there.
  • Pages that belong to no agent, like Settings or Memory, use Nox's yellow.

It works in both themes. In the light theme it's a pale wash of the colour on white; in the dark theme, a deep glow of it on near-black. When you move from one agent to another, the light fades from one colour to the next over about a second, so you notice the change without being startled by it.

Inbox's home: a green 3D face with horns and a green light behind the page
Move to another agent, and the light changes with it.

A touch of the same colour reaches the rest of the page, faintly: the sidebar is lit from its corner, the agent's card is washed in it at the top, and its computer, in the panel beside a task, is lit from its corner too.

A hotel booking waiting for an OK, with the agent's computer open on the right: faint yellow light in the corners of the sidebar and the computer panel
Beside a task, the agent's computer picks up its colour too.

The light moves very slowly, about one round every 36 seconds, and only the light moves, never the page. If your device is set to reduce motion, it stays still.

What you see, situation by situation

SituationIn nox.coolOn Nox's Mac Dock icon
Nothing at workFaces at restNo bar
One task, under 15 secondsIts face acts out the workNo bar
One task, longerIts face acts, the steps appear in its chatA bar that fills slowly and never starts over
Several tasksEach face actsHow many have finished since they began
Waiting for your OK or answerA card in the chatA number on the icon, no bar
Waiting for nox.cool's AIA plain note in the chatNo bar
DoneThe result in the chatThe bar goes

On a phone or in a browser, a long task sends one quiet notice after a few minutes and updates it in place, rather than a new alert for every step.

What we chose not to do

A few things look helpful and aren't:

  • No time estimates. "About 3 minutes left" is the same made-up percentage in different clothes. nox.cool says how long a task has been going, which is true.
  • No spinners. A working agent's face acts instead, so you see who is busy, not just that something is.
  • No glowing rings or pulsing around faces. We tried a pulsing ring; it was too much, and it came off.
  • No sounds for progress. Sound is for what needs you, like a call or an OK.

How to try it

  1. Sign in at nox.cool (anyone can make an account).
  2. Open one agent from the sidebar, then another, and watch the light change.
  3. To change an agent's colour, open the menu beside its name in the sidebar, choose Edit, and pick one of the eight colours under its face.
  4. On a Mac, give Nox a longer task, like "compare five note-taking apps and write me a one-page report", and watch the bar on its Dock icon fill slowly. Nox for Mac updates itself to the version with the new bar.

What's new in this update, in short, is in the announcement. To try it, open nox.cool.

Questions and answers

Why doesn't nox.cool show a percentage for a task?

Because nobody knows it. An AI agent picks each step after seeing the result of the last one, so a task that looks like six steps can take twenty. Any percentage would be a guess dressed up as a fact.

What does the bar on Nox's Dock icon mean?

With one task at work for more than 15 seconds, the bar fills slowly from when the task began and never starts over. With several, it shows how many have finished since they began. A task that's only waiting shows no bar.

How do I know when an agent needs me?

The task shows a card in its chat with what it wants to do, and the number on Nox's Dock icon counts the tasks waiting for you. Waiting tasks never show a progress bar, so a bar always means work is moving.

Can I tell my agents apart if I can't see colours well?

Yes. Colour is never the only sign: every agent also has its own name and its own face, shown wherever the colour is. The light behind the page is a help, not the only way to know.

Does the coloured light cost battery?

Very little. Only the light layer moves, about one slow round every 36 seconds, and nothing on the page is redrawn. With reduce motion turned on in your device's settings, it stays still.

Try it with Nox

Anyone can sign up: on the web, or with Nox for Mac.

Keep reading